Welcome to Stefano's Pizzeria & Restaurant
Stefano's Pizzeria & Restaurant, located at 258 State St in Carthage, NY, is a beloved local gem that marries tradition with vibrant flavors. Renowned for its diverse pizza offerings, from the Meat Lovers Combo to the Pesto Veggie Special, Stefano’s ensures that every bite is a celebration of taste. Diners rave about the homemade quality, generous portions, and welcoming atmosphere. With its friendly service and a family story that resonates through the years, Stefano’s has become a nostalgic favorite for many. Whether enjoying a freshly made pizza or their famed eggplant Parmesan, guests leave satisfied and eager to return.
-
258 State St, Carthage, NY 13619, United States258 State St, Carthage, NY 13619, United States Hotline: +1 315-493-0400
Welcome to Stefano's Pizzeria & Restaurant, a beloved culinary gem nestled in the heart of Carthage, NY, located at 258 State St. With a legacy that has woven itself into the fabric of this vibrant community, Stefano's stands as a testament to the joys of Italian cuisine, particularly the timeless craft of pizza-making.
As you step into Stefano's, you're greeted by a lively atmosphere that reflects both warmth and familiarity. It's a place where friends gather, families celebrate, and memories are made over delicious food. The friendly service you receive is not just a courtesy; it’s part of the charm that makes this establishment feel like home, even for its many out-of-town devotees.
The menu showcases the true essence of New York pizza, highlighted by customer favorites. One standout is the Sicilian pepperoni pizza with jalapeño peppers, a generous creation served in 16 delectable pieces. Patrons rave about the dough, describing it as “to die for,” perfectly balanced in texture and flavor. Each bite bursts with freshness, often leading to the delightful dilemma of wanting to savor it hot or enjoy it cold.
Beyond pizzas, the culinary offerings include mouthwatering garlic bread, both grilled and pesto-stuffed, and even big, luscious chocolate chip cookies that evoke a sense of nostalgia. The portions here are hearty, ensuring you leave satisfied, with many frequently noting that the meals offer great value for the quality provided.
What truly sets Stefano's apart is its rich family history and commitment to excellence—values echoed through the years by loyal patrons like Kevin Esslinger, who praises the eggplant Parmesan as some of the best he’s ever had. The combination of flavorful dishes and a welcoming environment keeps guests returning, some for decades. Whether you're a local or just passing through, your experience at Stefano's promises to be memorable.
Stefano's Pizzeria & Restaurant is more than just a place to eat; it's a community staple that beautifully captures the spirit of authentic Italian dining. For takeout or a sit-down meal, make sure to swing by or call at +1 315-493-0400 to dive into the delectable flavors that have locals returning time and time again!
Service and food were both excellent. They were able to accommodate our party of nine people. Excellent! Highly recommend.
Anytime I’m back in town I’m getting stefanos. This place is like home to me and the food is always so amazing. The atmosphere is vibrant, the service is friendly. Even eating their pizza cold is good. The dough is just to die for. I’ve been getting stefanos since I was a small child and it’s nice to see they have branched out! I’ll be here in Washington State hoping you will make it out here some day *sigh* ;)
Mouth watering and superbly fresh. The pizza definitely has a local homemade feel. I can surely see why this place gets the business. Great place to come for that New York pizza flavor! Such great portions too.
Great family story! We had sicilian pepperoni with jalapeno peppers and it was huge... 16 pieces. Pizza and garlic bread were fantastic, service was fast and friendly.
Always a value and amazing food and service! First restaurant that makes eggplant Parm as good as you can at home and that's the highest compliment there is! More food with a typical dinner order than you can possibly eat. Have never had a bad meal there in 30 years of frequenting this establishment!
I took my parents, brother, and his wife who are from Alabama to Stefanos Carthage location, as they hadn’t been there before. The spaghetti was wonderful, as were the riggies, and the sausage/peppers/mushrooms pizza was spot on. I personally have been to Stefanos many many times, and their performance on this occasion was no different from my past experiences. No let downs. The owner flat out knows what he is doing running his restaurants, and their product is just killer. Consistent, hot, fresh, and delicious. I’d recommend it to anyone. You can’t lose here!
Always happy eating here. Great portions. Good ingredients. Pizza reminds me of NYC. I come to work in Carthage a few days a month. This is the only place that makes me feel like I’m eating a home cooked meal. All what you see in the picture was 20 bucks . Leftovers for a whole meal and a to go drink to boot. Thank you Emma
Our favorite authentic Italian restaurant in Carthage NY. We've never had a bad meal here ever, we def recommend the pepperoni knots!